Testing Designs by Changing Only One Thing
Atlas stands at a wooden workbench cluttered with paper bridges, small weights, and sticky notes, carefully lowering a penny onto one bridge while the other three identical bridges wait in a row behind him.
- Explain why engineers change only one thing at a time when testing a design.
- Identify which part of a test is being changed and which parts are being kept the same.
- Compare two test results and explain what the difference tells you.
- Predict what would happen to your results if you changed two things at once.
Key terms
- fair test
- a test that changes only one thing
- variable
- the one thing you change on purpose
- controlled variable
- a thing you keep the same
- result
- what happens at the end of a test
Change Just One Thing
A fair test means you change exactly one thing and keep everything else the same. The one thing you change is called the variable. If you change two things at once, you cannot tell which one mattered. Say one bridge is wider and also folded differently. If it holds more weight, was it the width or the folds? You will never know. Changing one thing keeps the test honest and clear.
Keep the Rest the Same
The parts you keep the same are called controlled variables. You control them, which means you hold them steady. If you test if thick rubber bands launch farther, you keep the same arm, the same angle, and the same ball. Only the rubber band changes. Now any change you see must come from the rubber band. That is how you know your answer is true and not a lucky guess.
Worked examples
Mia swaps a thicker rubber band but keeps everything else the same. Is it fair?
- Check what she changed: just the rubber band.
- Check what stayed the same: arm, angle, ball.
- Only one thing changed.
Answer: Yes, it is a fair test.
Plane A is longer AND has wider wings than Plane B. What is wrong?
- Two things are different at once.
- You cannot tell which one helped.
Answer: It is not fair, because two things changed together.
Activity
Sort each test plan into Fair Test or Not a Fair Test, then explain your choice.
Practice
Decide if changing two ramp things at once is fair.
Plan a fair test for which paper folds the strongest.
Common mistakes to avoid
- Change many things to save timeChanging many things hides which one caused the result.
- Testing once makes it fairTesting once is fine, but you still change only one thing.
Check your understanding
Mia wants to find out if a thicker rubber band makes a catapult launch farther. She uses the same catapult arm, the same launch angle, and the same ball, but swaps in a thicker rubber band. What makes this a fair test?
Jaylen tested two paper planes. Plane A was longer AND had wider wings than Plane B. Plane A flew farther. What is the PROBLEM with Jaylen's test?
An engineer says, 'I will change the height of the ramp AND the weight of the car at the same time to save time.' What is most likely to go wrong?
Recap
A fair test changes only one thing, called the variable, and keeps everything else the same. The parts you hold steady are controlled variables. Then any change in the result must come from the one thing you changed.
Reflect
What one thing would you change in your next fair test?