The Different Jobs of a Judge and a Jury
Justice stands in a bright courtroom holding a gavel, pointing to a judge seated high at the bench and twelve jurors seated in rows to the side, while sunlight streams through tall windows onto the polished wooden floor.
- Explain what a judge does during a trial.
- Explain what a jury does during a trial.
- Compare the judge's job with the jury's job using their own words.
- Identify which role decides the rules and which role decides the facts.
- Predict what would happen if a trial had no judge or no jury.
Key terms
- judge
- the person who runs the trial
- jury
- a group of ordinary people who decide
- verdict
- the jury's decision about what happened
- defendant
- the person accused of doing wrong
The Judge Runs The Rules
A judge is like a referee in a sport. The judge sits up high and is in charge of running the whole trial. The judge makes sure everyone follows the rules, like what evidence can be shown and how lawyers must behave. The judge keeps order so the trial stays fair from start to finish. The judge controls the rules of the courtroom, but in a jury trial does not decide who is right.
The Jury Decides Facts
The jury is a group of ordinary people, usually twelve, chosen from the community. Their job is to listen very carefully to everything said and shown in the trial. Then they decide what really happened. Did the defendant do it or not? The jury decides the facts, and their answer is called a verdict. Both jobs are needed, because a fair trial needs someone to run it and someone to decide.
Worked examples
In a jury trial, who decides what really happened?
- The judge controls the rules of the trial.
- The jury listens to the evidence carefully.
- The jury decides the facts and gives a verdict.
Answer: The jury decides the facts, because ordinary people listen and decide together.
Two lawyers argue about whether a piece of evidence is allowed. Who rules?
- Deciding what evidence is allowed is a rule about the trial.
- The judge is in charge of the rules.
- So the judge makes this decision, not the jury.
Answer: The judge decides, because controlling the rules is the judge's job.
Activity
Sort each description into the correct job: does it belong to the Judge or the Jury?
Practice
Explain the judge's job using your own simple words.
Tell what the jury decides at the end of a trial.
Common mistakes to avoid
- The judge decides the verdict.In a jury trial the jury decides the facts and gives the verdict.
- The jury makes the courtroom rules.The judge controls the rules; the jury only decides what happened.
Check your understanding
In a jury trial, whose job is it to decide what the facts are — what really happened?
A lawyer tries to show a piece of evidence, but the other lawyer objects. Who decides whether the evidence is allowed?
Marcus thinks that because the judge runs the trial, the judge must also decide whether the defendant — the person accused of doing something wrong — is guilty. Is Marcus correct?
Recap
A trial has two big jobs. The judge runs the trial like a referee and controls the rules. The jury is ordinary people who listen carefully and decide the facts, giving a verdict. The judge controls rules; the jury decides facts.
Reflect
Think about why a trial needs both a judge and a jury.